Leadership Team

Say hello to New Song's leadership team.

senior Pastor

Pastor Justin Chambers and his wife Jennifer moved to Plymouth in 2004 in order to start a life-giving church. At that time, NSC was just a dream; by the grace of God, it's now a reality. From the first time you meet them, you'll see the depth of their love, not only for New Singers, but for our entire community.


They married in 1999 and have four beautiful children (Isaac, Isaiah, Grace and Delight). They absolutely love spending time together as a family, as well as traveling, leading mission trips and spending time outdoors. The only issue they have as a family is that Pastor Justin and his two boys are die-hard Green Bay Packer fans; Jennifer and the two girls love the Chicago Bears. YIKES!

Student Pastor

Pastor Josh Johnson joined the New Song staff in 2014. He and his wife Mallorie were married in 2011 and have 2 fantastic children, Graeme and Rylee.

Together they have a strong devotion to Jesus, a sincere love for teenagers, and are committed to leading teens on a journey to Know God, Find Freedom, Discover Purpose and Make a Difference.

In his free time Pastor Josh enjoys movie nights and game nights with his family. He also has a passion for the game of golf. Fun Fact -- Pastor Josh has had the honor to compete on several of the Top 100 Golf Courses in the World including; Bay Hill Club & Lodge (FL), Medinah Country Club (IL), St. Andrews Golf Club (Scotland), Carnoustie (Scotland), Turnberry (Scotland) and Pinehurst #2 (NC).

Children's Pastor

Pastor Stephanie Stichter serves as the Children's Pastor here at NSC. Stephanie has a background in kids camp ministry and has spent the last 9 years working as a high school athletic trainer since graduating from Anderson University in 2012.

She has a passion for adventures, travel, and learning new things! In her free time, you'll find her reading a book, working on a sewing / crocheting project, or planning her next travel adventure around the globe! 

Worship Pastor - Plymouth Campus

Pastor Evan Sumner is the newest member of the NSC staff, having joined us in 2021. Pastor Evan serves as the worship pastor at the Plymouth Campus. He has a passion for the New England Patriots, God, his wife Kourtney, and their dog Penny, but not necessarily in that order!

He enjoys being in community and you will often find him on the golf course or meticulously manicuring his lawn in his free time.

Pastoral Counselor

Bill Krogel

Dr. Bill Krogel has been a licensed marriage and family therapist for 25 years and has been a Professor at Grace College and Theological Seminary for the past 18 years.

He and his wife, Anita, love God, love others and love life. He's passionate about helping others grow in their relationship with the Lord and experience the freedom that God wants all of us to enjoy!

Campus Pastor - Wabash

Tony and Sherry Mercer

Pastor Tony and Sherry have been married for 20 years and have two children, Kelvin and Kendall. Since 2007, whether serving in student ministry or as lead pastors their lives have been focused on loving God and loving people. Their God-given dream of leading a life-giving church came to pass in 2019 when Pastor Justin and Jennifer Chambers invited them to be the Campus Pastors at NSC's second location in Wabash, IN. It won't take you long to discover what they live for - helping others know God, find freedom, discover purpose and make a difference.


Alexander Finney is the worship pastor at New Song Church - Wabash. He enjoys making a joyful noise to the Lord. He knew he was called into worship ministry around the time that he turned thirteen. Ever since then he has spent many years practicing his craft, and is excited to share what he knows, and grow alongside NSC Wabash.

If you catch Alex outside of the church, you'll probably see him spending time outside. Whether he is riding his bike, hiking, camping, or kayaking, there's a good chance you'll find him enjoying God's creation.

He is ecstatic to begin his journey with NSC Wabash, and is ready to see what God has planned for this place because there is no doubt that it is good.


Sue Schieber has been attending New Song since she arrived in Plymouth in 2012. She has been involved in ministry with her husband, Rich, for 30 years as a youth pastor, teacher, missionary to Guatemala, and Teen Bible Quiz coordinator. 

She enjoys spending time with her family (especially her two grandsons), traveling and studying God's Word.

Have a question or two for our Leadership Team?